MIDEAST: US JOURNALISTS, STORY STILL UNCLEAR

(by Lorenzo Trombetta)
(ANSAmed) - BEIRUT, OCTOBER 10 - A series of questions
without answers leaves some dark spots on the happy ending to
the story of the two American journalists, disappearing first
in Lebanon and then reappearing in Syria where hey were taken
into custody with the excuse that they had entered the
country illegally. Taylor Luck and Holli Chmela, 23 and 27
years old, journalists for Amman's Jordan Times, returned
home to the Jordanian capital ''safe and sound'' early this
morning. Yesterday evening, nine days after they disappeared,
they were released by Syrian authorities and handed over to
officials from the US Embassy in Damascus. Upon his arrival
in the Jordanian capital, Luck told ANSA his version of the
facts, which are in contrast to the official Syrian one.
Damascus accused the two of having entered the country
illegally ''with the help of a smuggler''. ''After arriving
near to the Lebanon-Syria border - Luck said this morning -
the taxi driver and his accomplice tried to rob us, when a
military vehicle appeared and some soldiers got out. They
took our passports and cellular phones and loaded us in the
transport''. ''After which we realized we were in Syria - his
version continues - but we decided to say that we were
tourists and not journalists. They took us to a prison near
Homs (160km north of Damascus) where we remained, in separate
cells from October 1st to October 8th''. ''At the moment of
our transfer to a military prison in Damascus, an official
identified Holli from the photos seen on TV and we were
identified as 'the two missing journalists'. Only at that
point - he adds - were we handed over to the US Embassy in
Damascus''. Luck concludes: ''In any case we were treated
well and they seemed to understand the difficulty of our
situation. Maybe we were naive, but in any case we were
victims''. Luck's version is also different from that which
appeared today in the Lebanese and Pan-Arabian press: for a
''Syrian security source'' quoted in the pro-Syrian newspaper
as-Safir in Beirut, the two journalists ''had gone to a
travel agency in northern Lebanon in order to go to Syria.
When they discovered that it would be difficult to
enter without visas, they accepted the offer to cross the
border with a taxi driver who was in contact with some
smugglers''. The passage, which cost a little under 100 euros
total (6,000 Syrian lire), is said to have taken place in the
Wadi Khaled border area, not far from where they were
arrested by a Syrian border patrol. According to the source
quoted by as-Safir, the episode happened yesterday, and not
October 1st.
According to the reconstruction of the Pan-Arabian
newspaper al-Hayat edited in London, Luck and Chmela were not
headed to Syria before October 7th: eye-witnesses quoted by
the newspaper confirm to have seen the two young Americans in
Beirut's crowded nightclubs at least as recent as October
6th. Their ''illegal'' passage to Syria, in fact there is no
trace of them in Lebanese border records, whether it was
accidental (as Luck sustains) or voluntary (as the Syrians
sustain), according to al-Hayat it happened at the earliest
the night of October 7th. (ANSAmed).